- 2009 Inaugural Productions
- The Bear
- Riders to the Sea
- 2009-2010 Season
- Frightening Funny Family Fun
- The Flying Doctor
- On Baile’s Strand
- Murder, You Must Be Kidding!
- 2010-2011 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense I
- Antigone
- Picasso at Lapin Agile
- 2011-2012 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense II
- Bittersweet Love
- Rhinoceros
- 2012-2013 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense III
- Desire, Desire, Desire,
- The Good Doctor
- Oedipus the Musical
- 2013-2014 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense IV
- Les Liaisons Dangereuses
- Romeo and Juliet
- Drones, Clones, and Phones
- 2014-2015 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense V
- Arcadia
- Musical of Musicals: The Musical
- 2015-2016 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense VI
- 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
- Proof
- Jar the Floor
- An Ideal Husband
- The Tempest
- 2016-2017 Season
- 2017-2018 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense VIII
- Rashomon
- Collected Stories
- Anton in Show Business
- As You Like It
- 2018-2019 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense IX
- Mariana Pineda
- The Last Days of Judas Iscariot
- Buddha Swings
- A Midsummer Night’s Dream
- 2019-2020 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense X
- Airline Highway
- She Kills Monsters
- (Spring mainstage show and summer Shakespeare canceled by pandemic)
- 2020-2021 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense 2020 (virtual)
- 2021-2022 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense 2021
- The Importance of Being Earnest
- Much Ado About Nothing
- 2022-2023 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense 2022
- The Alcestiad
- Everybody
- Macbeth
- 2023-2024 Season
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense 2023
- The Real Nightmare (The Actor’s Nightmare and The Real Inspector Hound)
- Do You Feel Anger?
- The Merry Wives of Windsor
- 2024-2025
- An Evening of Horror and Suspense 2024
- Eurydice
- Sabrina Fair
- The Taming of the Shrew